A brief history of the ideological capture of social work

social work

As with teaching, the profession of social work has become completely captured by the ideology of gender identity over the past decade.

It has happened in the same way; a combination of the lobbying of activist groups and individuals coupled with government initiatives and support from the well-meaning and gullible professionals with collective amnesia regarding normal rules of safeguarding and understanding of the vulnerabilities of looked-after children.

The result has been a total failure of care and a disproportionate number of these troubled children sent to the gender clinic.

The background:

In her interim report Dr Hilary Cass highlighted the disproportionate number of looked-after children referred to the Tavistock GIDS. She said

“In discussion with social workers, we heard concerns about how looked after children are supported in getting the help and support they need.”

The figures are stark. A study of Tavistock GIDS referrals 2009 – 2011 found:

  • Looked after children make up 0.58% of the general population but 4.9% of GIDS referrals.

Adopted children account for another 3.8% of referrals. (Gender Dysphoria in looked-after and adopted young people in a gender identity development service Matthews et al 2019)

The Cass Review final report documented the percentages from a systematic review (Taylor et al: Patient characteristics):

  • loss of parent through abandonment resulting in adoption (1-8%), foster care (1-12%) or children’s home placement (0.5 – 5%).

The Review also included figures from the Tavistock GIDS:

However, a review of the first 124 cases seen by GIDS (Di Ceglie et al., 2002) found that just over a quarter of all referrals had spent some time in care and nearly half of all referrals had experienced living with only one parent. It showed that 42% of the children covered by the audit experienced the loss of one or both parents, mainly through separation; 38% had family physical health problems; and 38% had family mental health problems. Physical abuse was documented in 15% of cases. [p. 94]

In research of comparative referral rates across regional NHS clinical commissioning groups, Blackpool came top with the highest number of referrals to GIDS.

Blackpool also has the highest number of looked after children in England at 218 per 10,000.

NE Lincolnshire, who came 6th in referrals to GIDS has the second highest rate of looked after children in England, 186 per 10,000.

It should be an issue of great concern that a disproportionate number of children in care, who often have underlying, complex mental health problems, are distressed about their gender and reject their bodies, but it is not surprising.This is the most vulnerable cohort of children who were failed at the GIDS.

We know the activist gender affirmative approach at the GIDS put children at risk of unnecessary, life-changing medical intervention. But the gender affirmative approach is also practised widely among professionals working with children in other areas such as schools and social services.

As soon as a child declares they are trans, all other factors are ignored and the child is placed outside normal safeguarding frameworks. Cass called the focus on ‘gender’ at the exclusion of all other factors ‘diagnostic overshadowing.’

One of the worst examples we’ve heard of agencies’ total failure to safeguard a child is a recent example from New Zealand. In their zeal to affirm the ‘gender identity’ of an autistic girl who had suffered childhood sexual abuse, they were blind to the fact that she was dying of anorexia. This is what ‘diagnostic overshadowing’ means in reality. It is not something that happens only in clinics, it happens in schools and social care as soon as a child declares they are ‘transgender.’  

The way that gender identity ideology has infiltrated local authorities and social services is the same as the way it’s become embedded in schools. It began before the Women and Equality Select Committee’s Trans Equality inquiry in 2015 chaired by Maria Miller, but it exploded afterwards, with government support.

A brief timeline of the capture of social work by activists:

  • In 2013 an agency called Three Circles Fostering started the LGBT Youth in Care project in Manchester. They worked with the LGBT Foundation and Care Leavers Association.
  • In 2014 Three Circles Fostering produced an information leaflet for foster carers. By putting the LGB and the T together, they were able to present the idea that a child who thought they were the opposite sex required exactly the same approach as for a child who had come out as gay.

They worked with Mermaids, The Proud Trust and a trans youth group to develop a toolkit for supporting trans children in care, having found there weren’t any existing resources.

Now known as LGBTQ+ Youth in Care it can advise the same for a child who is ‘Q+’ whatever that means, and it boasts that it is a network of LGBTQ+ care leavers, local authorities, care organisations, residential care providers, independent fostering agencies and supported accommodation providers.  

SpeakOut was a national study run by the University of East Anglia, investigating lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and questioning (LGBTQ) young people’s experiences of the care system, funded by the Economic and Social Research Council. It ran between 2014 and 2017.

  • In response to the 2015 Women and Equalities Select Committee Trans Equality Inquiry recommendations, the government committed to ensuring all public sector professionals receive adequate training on gender identity and gender variance.

That year the Department for Education (DfE) also commissioned a study from the NIESR on the adequacy and consistency of child and family social worker education in regard to gender identity and gender variance.

  • In 2017 a SpeakOut stakeholder event was held with representatives from ‘the main LGBT organisations, Children in Care charities, DfE, and Government Equalities Office.’

That year Three Circles Fostering published Trans Youth in Care – a toolkit for social care professionals, written by LGBTQ+ Youth in Care in collaboration with The Proud Trust, The National Teaching & Advisory Service, Three Circles Fostering, the LGBT foundation, Mermaids, Sparkle and the Trans Equality Legal Initiative. It is an activist manifesto.

A leaflet Trans Youth in Foster Care was also produced for children. ‘Know Your Rights!’ it proclaimed, telling children:

If your foster carers will not help or accept your gender identity – they are wrong. You have the right to be accepted, write it down or call us on 01625 533 531 so we can put it right.

And:

You have the right to use the bathroom you feel most comfortable in.

Mermaids, in the section on their website “supporting a trans child as a social worker” states:

“Supporting children and young people to live as their affirmed gender is very important to nurture self-esteem and self-confidence.  In some cases a child’s gender expression may change but allowing them freedom of expression is vital to maintaining good mental health.”

The DfE report framed the issue as one of rights rather than safeguarding: “Rapid Review evidence suggests childhood gender dysphoria remains poorly understood by social workers, resulting in transgender people experiencing discrimination.”

The report included ‘gender nonconformity’ under the definition of ‘transgender.’

“Transgender, often abbreviated to ‘trans’, is an umbrella term used to describe people whose gender identity and/or gender expression differs from the sex they were assigned at birth. The term ‘transgender’ therefore covers a wide spectrum of gender nonconformity and gender variance that exhibits both complexity and fluidity.”

  • In 2019 anAll-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) for Looked After Children and Care Leavers held a meeting in the House of Commons with speakers from the University of East Anglia Speak Out project and the LGBTQ+ Youth in Care project from Three Circles Fostering. The Become Charity has acted as secretariat of the APPG group since its establishment in 1998 and they reported on the meeting:

There was a clear demand for improved – and mandatory – training for foster carers and social workers around issues of inclusivity, acceptance and identity.

The panel suggested ways to create a more visibly inclusive environment, such as wearing rainbow lanyards, displaying positive literature and using non-gendered language.

  • In 2021 the British Association of Social Workers (BASW) published a position statement on social work with transgender people, based on principles including the right to self-determination, social justice, challenging oppression and respecting diversity. ‘Turning ethics into practice’ includes:

Understanding how gender identity and transitioning issues affect people at different life stages and in different contexts, and understanding the role and responsibilities of social workers in dealing with the decision making and rights dilemmas that can arise (e.g., for a child/young person considering their gender or sex and their parents/guardians, or for an adult with impaired mental capacity)

The same year Social Work England joined the Stonewall Diversity Champions scheme, leaving in 2022 to join the LGBT Foundation’s training academy.

  • In 2023 Cafcass, the children and family court advisory and support service and the largest employer of social workers in England, published new guidance based on LGBTQ+ Trans Youth in Care guide.

Over just a decade, the services working with children in the care system had become totally ideologically captured.

This is a dereliction of duty towards society’s most vulnerable children. When all professionals involved with the safeguarding of children in the care system are obediently following the ‘gender affirming’ approach of activists, it is not surprising that so many of these children end up in the gender clinic.

The Impact of the capture of social work

Two cases in 2016 illustrate the capture of social services. The first was a court case which concerned a 7 year-old boy, J. His mother was dressing her son in girls’ clothes and was insisting he was transgender.

The doctor in the case considered the mother had caused significant emotional harm to J in her active determination that he should be a girl. The court noted that the Local Authority had moved into wholesale acceptance that J should be regarded as a girl when he was only 4 years old.

The judge said

“Professionals failed properly to investigate, in part because they did not wish to appear to be challenging an emerging orthodoxy in such a high-profile issue.”

This family was supported by Mermaids, one of the charities advising on social work guidance, who were ordered by the court to have nothing to do with the child.

The second, the case of a teenage girl, was an example of a story we have heard from an increasing number of parents who have been threatened by social services that their child may be taken into care if they fail to ‘affirm their gender identity.’ The mother in this case said

“The social worker has pressed us to this position, where we felt coerced and manipulated; that if we did not comply with their wishes, our daughter could possibly be taken away from us.

“I feel like they are following an agenda, that the child should be listened to above all, even when the child is young and the parents’ wishes for their child can be superceded by social services.”

A guest post written for us by a foster carer in 2019 distressingly revealed the extent to which normal standards of care have been denied these children. The foster mother says:

“I’m not happy with any of the authorities that’s been involved in the last year even social services telling me I’ve got to call her the name she wants to be called. Bringing me phone numbers to contact mermaids.”

“Transgender youth club that she does go to which i want to stop her from going but then I feel I’ll be in trouble by social services.”

Where have social workers learned to ignore parents and foster parents and discount their knowledge of their own child or the child they are caring for? We have to look at the guidance and training they have received, together with the position taken by the regulators.

The Trans Youth in Care toolkit for Caring Professionals

This toolkit starts from the position that some children are ‘transgender’ and that professionals must only listen to them and believe them. It uses the suggestions of children themselves, through a consultation which asked them ‘what makes good care for a trans child or young person?’

Children’s answers are used to justify the recommendations in the toolkit, without any curiosity about why children themselves believe things such as “One revealing mistake with names or pronouns can be devastating. More than most, trans children have their very core identity denied”, which sounds suspiciously learned from a script.

As children repeat the narrative they’ve heard online or in school, it is a safe bet that in asking them questions you’ll get the answers you want to justify guidance like this. And who can ignore such guidance when it’s children themselves telling you what they need? This is a common tactic employed by groups such as Stonewall.

From ‘children’s voices’ we get advice like this:

If a young person tells you they are trans and want to transition it’s safe to say that they are pretty sure about it. We must be open and curious about a young person’s gender identity and support them through their transition in whatever way we can.

When we say the Trans Youth in Care toolkit is an activist manifesto we are not exaggerating. It proclaims:

“This toolkit is about educating the masses, not just the few.”

It instructs professionals to ‘promote a non-binary society’, ‘try to foster a gender neutral and gender exploring environment’ and:

Be prepared to learn a new language when it comes to understanding and discussing issues of gender identity.

It suggests that it is ‘good practice’ to ask every child what their pronouns are when meeting them, that this will ‘instantly put a young person at ease’ and that a professional should:

Never assume a persons [sic] gender based on appearance. Use the pronouns they, them, theirs until you have identified the correct pronoun of an individual.

It reports that some foster carers ‘were not supportive and refused to use their correct pronouns’, that a professional must ‘accept the young person for who they are in every way’ and states unequivocally:

Some of the young people we spoke with experienced care that did not affirm their gender identity, this is unacceptable.

When a social worker meets such families, this is the advice:

We must empower young people to challenge when their pronoun is used incorrectly and we must advocate for them in meetings.

To ensure that foster carers are fully on board with the programme, agencies should:

Ask trans specific questions during the recruitment of foster carers, make sure your application forms are trans inclusive. Challenge transphobia from foster carers and others through education and supervision.

Just like Stonewall, Trans Youth in Care uses the Equality Act 2010 to give the impression that all of this is a legal duty:

All agencies working with young people must ensure they provide fully inclusive services. This may include things like training to staff, access to bathrooms, using gender neutral language.

And it gives the inevitable advice on referral to the Tavistock GIDS, with the usual minimisation of serious medical intervention:

A young person may be diagnosed with Gender Dysphoria and access various support from the GIDS including access to hormone blockers, if required.

There is also the inevitable section on confidentiality, which should never be a requirement of professionals working with vulnerable children:

Share information only when the young person is ready. If we share without consent, this may lead to the young person feeling out of control of their identity and being forced to come out to others before they are ready.

In an appendix information is given on binders, packers and tucking, as if all of this is healthy and normal, and it is suggested that:

You could signpost young people to websites or literature that detail what resources are available so that they can make a choice about what they might want.

The Cafcass guidance

The CAFCASS guidance, based on LGBTQ+ Trans Youth in Care guide, simply repeats the transactivist message, despite being published after the Cass Interim report in 2022, which should have raised alarm in the profession.

Like the activist groups, it disregards the findings of Cass and sums up the Interim Report as merely proving that there is a “paucity of provision for transgender children.” There is nothing on their website that acknowledges the Cass Review final report, but there is a link to Top Tips from Allsorts.

Cafcass presents medical transition as normal and unproblematic:

Social transition is later, for some, accompanied by other steps which require professional support such as puberty blockers, cross hormones, and surgery, but in the UK, these are very difficult to access, and health care provision is inadequate as evidenced by the interim report of Dr Hilary Cass who is reviewing Gender Identity Services for Children.

The guidance tells us that ‘gender identity is not a lifestyle choice‘ and that:

Any suggestion that some children state they are transgender for attention, because they have been influenced by social media or others such as parents is wrong.

It warns practitioners that children may sometimes be exposed to information on reality (but not that children are constantly exposed to the idea of subjective ‘gender identity’):

Children are not immune to being exposed to high profile gender critical views and the fact they are children does not protect them from its everyday impact or inhibit those making such assertions.

It also gives a clear warning that practitioners must not consider any other factor which may have contributed to the child’s feelings of distress, they must accept without question that the child is ‘trans’:

Direct or indirect conversion therapy is morally and ethically wrong and the child should be permitted to express their gender in accordance with their needs.

It also repeats the old Keeping Children Safe in Education guidance which was written by Stonewall, but has now changed:

Being transgender is not a child protection issue or safeguarding concern in itself.

As with the Trans Youth in Care toolkit, unquestioning gender affirmation is presented as the only legitimate approach, and Cafcass assumes these are the only reasons parents would fail to do this:

Others however may react less positively at first because they have inaccurate or incomplete information, or because they are worried about what it will mean for their child and their future life path. Some parents simply do not accept that transgender people exist and carry prejudice and bigotry that they project onto their child.

Chillingly, it suggests that it is only not affirming a child’s ‘gender identity’ that may be considered a safeguarding issue:

Practitioners can support parents in permitting their children explore their gender identity at any age. Where a child is being suppressed or denied this, it should be assessed in safeguarding terms and whether the exercise of parental responsibility is being used in the best interest of the child. Parental responsibility does not permit abuse of the child in any form.

As resources, the guidance links to Gendered Intelligence, Mermaids, GIRES, Stonewall, TransActual, Pop’n’Olly, Just Like Us and Trans Legal Project. There are no alternative views considered.

Social workers

The position of local authorities and social work regulators has been made clear in two high-profile legal cases of social workers sanctioned for their so-called ‘gender critical beliefs’: Rachel Meade in 2022 against Westminster City Council and Social Work England, and Lizzy Pitt in 2023 against Cambridgeshire County Council.

Rachel Meade was sanctioned and then suspended by Social Work England for her belief that a person cannot change their sex, after a vexatious complaint was made based on posts she had shared to friends on Facebook. She pursued a claim for harassment and sex discrimination against SWE and Westminster City Council where she had worked for 20 years. (We attended the first hearing as a witness).

Rachel won her case against both in 2024 and was awarded aggravated damages. Social Work England were also ordered to pay exemplary damages, the first time this has happened to a regulator. The Tribunal also made recommendations that both Social Work England and Westminster City Council provide training to managers on freedom of expression and protected belief.

Social Work England issued this statement, saying ‘We have already started implementing our learning from this case.’ However, there was no apology to Rachel and the learning they describe seems to be more focused on legalities, social media policies and complaints procedures, rather than a review of their own strongly-held ideological position that led to the discrimination against Rachel.

Lizzy Pitt is a lesbian who was subject to a disciplinary process after a group complaint by colleagues for expressing her views that sex is real and it matters, during a workplace LGBTQIA group meeting.

She sued her employer, Cambridgeshire County Council (CCC), for harassment and discrimination based on her protected belief. In 2024 she won her Employment Tribunal when CCC surrendered on the morning of the first hearing, admitting that they had discriminated against her and agreeing to pay the compensation.

They also agreed, after some negotiation, to a recommendation from the tribunal that they should add a compulsory module to their e-learning on freedom of belief and expression in the workplace.

Have things changed Post-Cass?

The British Association of Social Workers (BASW), in their response to the Cass Review final report said:

While the Cass Review is a crucial first step, the emphasis on a broader multi-disciplinary approach might provide important opportunities to ensure social workers can be effectively engaged with such work. BASW will think carefully about the implications of this for social work.

In June 2024, BASW chair Julia Ross published an outline of social work’s role, saying that ‘the Cass Review has also requested that we further consider the safeguarding aspects’ and concluding:

However, the Cass review recommendations set out a different approach to healthcare, more closely aligned with usual NHS clinical practice that considers the young person holistically and not solely in terms of their gender-related distress.

They also published a thoughtful piece on the approach to social transition, referencing Cass, from a CAMHS practitioner in May this year, who concluded with the acknowledgment that so many of these children will be struggling with emerging same-sex attraction:

We must get better at recognising the complexity of sexual identity, rather than conflating it with gender identity.

However, BASW has not reviewed or modified its 2021 position statement on social work with transgender people, which fails to consider the safeguarding aspects of working with children who identify as ‘transgender.’

The Association of Child Protection Professionals also published a response in support of the Cass final report, saying:

The Final Report is a welcome review of the evidence and the AoCPP supports the recommendations which we consider to be in the best interests of children and young people with gender dysphoria.

Social Work England, however, has issued no response to the Cass Review final report.

Meanwhile in Scotland, unbelievably, it is the organisation LGBT Youth Scotland (LGBTYS) who have been trusted to advise on policy for children in care. We have written of our concerns about this charity, with its history of paedophilia and sex abuse. Nevertheless the Care Inspectorate Scotland employed LGBTYS to help develop the first version of their Guidance for children and young people’s services on the inclusion of transgender including non-binary young people.

This hit the headlines in March for advising that girls in care should share a bedroom with boys who ‘self-identify’ as girls. Taking away safeguarding of girls is a built-in feature of the trans movement. Even vulnerable girls in care are left unprotected. No transgender lobby group should be anywhere near guidance for children in care, let alone one with a record of child sexual abuse.

The guidance was published in 2021 and updated to supposedly reflect the Cass Review, but did not include her actual findings or pay any attention to the recommendations. It was updated again in May this year to take account of the Supreme Court judgment but only paid lip service to it, stating the rule that single sex provision must be based on biological sex, but following with this statement:

We would suggest that discussions with young people and robust risk assessment should inform individualised approaches for each young person.

There is pushback from within the profession. Established in 2021, the Evidence-Based Social Work Alliance (EBSWA) is a coalition of qualified practitioners, academics and social work students who are concerned about the uncritical use of gender identity theory in social work and other professions and how this undermines the safeguarding of children.

A member of EBSWA, ‘Emma’ had her article Why Social Workers Need to be Talking about Gender Identity published in Social Work News in October last year, a sign we hope that the debate is beginning to happen openly within the profession. This piece, on the other hand, Reflections on caring for a transgender young person, was published by Buckinghamshire Council two days after the final Cass Review was published. There is still a long way to go.

Conclusion

There’s a huge pushback now from parents about the infiltration of trans activist gender identity ideology, gender affirmation and social transition in schools. But children in local authority care may have no parents to advocate for them, and are more needing of government protection.

Adding transgender to a conversion therapy bill would make things worse for this cohort because if it applies to children the government will be putting the concept of the ‘transgender child’ into the statute and creating a chilling effect on professionals and parents if they fail to ‘affirm’ a child’s ‘gender identity.’

The regulators have failed to put safeguarding first in allowing unqualified transgender activist organisations to influence social work policy. Recent tribunals and family court cases, the Cass Review, the Sullivan Review and the Supreme Court judgment all point the way back to reality if the regulators, authorities and agencies are willing to take it.

With compassion it is easy to see how children who are not securely attached, and who have been failed by parents and state authorities, are particularly susceptible to the flattery of a new ‘family’ and the idea of burying your old self and becoming a different person. Newly-acquired power, status, acceptance and the promise of rebirth are a heady mix of rewards for the child who has felt no power in their lives, nor love and acceptance.

The ‘trans’ family, with its flags and promises of ‘euphoria’ has no conditions for entry except a self-declaration of belief. The exceptionalism promoted by the LGBTQ+ Youth in Care and Cafcass guidance is part of the activist narrative that covers up what is really going on for these distressed and vulnerable children. The job of the social work profession is to see through the false promise of miraculous reinvention being sold to children and recognise that the destabilisation of reality and erasure of boundaries is the last thing that the most vulnerable children need.

Listen to the latest EBSWA podcast here: Maggie Mellon, social worker and founder of EBSWA introduces Stephanie Davies Arai, founder and director of Transgender Trend and Robin Carling, social worker and member of EBSWA, in conversation on some of these issues.

This Post Has 2 Comments

  1. Ian Court

    Tragically, those most prone to culture bound social contagions appear to be adult professionals with child and vulnerable adult, safeguarding responsibilities. The youngest child in my area that I am aware of being ‘socially transitioned’ by the authorities, was two years of age. The next, four. This is not and never has been a civil rights issue, it is a mental health crisis and an ongoing crime scene. The Cass inspired puberty blocker trials on potentially up to 6 thousand children, are due to start any day soon, with the blessing of our government. Words fail to convey the full horror of what has happened and will happen. Words fail.

  2. Tim Davies

    An excellent article that forensically dissects the truly shocking capture of social work by gender ideology.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.